Old West Lawmen List – D

Lawman Summaries (name begins with) A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z

C. N. DaggerU.S. Deputy Marshal commissioned in the Southern District at Paris, Texas, serving under Marshal Sheb Williams. On November 1, 1890, a dispatch was received from Vernon, Texas, stating that Dagger had been shot in Kiowa and Comanche country and was in dire need of assistance.

Crawley P. Dake

Crawley P. Dake

Crawley P. Dake (1827-1890)Union soldier during the Civil War and U.S. Marshal for Arizona Territory from 1878 to 1882. Dake was born in Ontario, Canada in 1827 (some publications indicate 1836) but moved with his family to Ogdensburg, New York when he was a child. When he grew up, he operated a retail store in Michigan, but when the Civil War broke out, he raised a company of soldiers and was commissioned in the 5th Michigan Cavalry. He served at Gettysburg and in several other major actions until he was wounded and retired as a major in August 1864. He then worked for the Internal Revenue Service for a time before being appointed as the U.S. Marshal for Arizona Territory on June 12, 1878. For the first two years, he dispatched several posses to the Mexican border, attempting to control the lawlessness taking place there. Several well-known frontier characters worked for him, including Leslie Blackburn, Virgil and Wyatt Earp, Joseph Evans, Joe Phy, and others. After the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral in Tombstone, Arizona, in October 1881, he was heavily criticized and replaced in July 1882. He remained in Arizona, living in Prescott, managing mining and business interests until his death on August 9, 1890.

Frank Dalton (1859-1887) – The older brother of the boys who formed the Dalton Gang, Frank was a U.S. Deputy Marshal at Fort Smith, Arkansas. Involved in several gunfights during his short career, he was killed, along with Deputy J.R. Cole, in 1887 by a man named Dave Smith.

Grattan “Grat” Dalton (1865-1892) – A member of the deadly Dalton Gang, Grat was first a U.S. Deputy Marshal before he chose a life a crime — a decision that would get him killed in the Coffeyville Raid.

Edwin B. Daniels (18??-1874) –  A deputy sheriff in St. Clair County, Missouri, Daniels was traveling with Pinkerton Agents Louis Lull and James Boyle, searching for the elusive Younger brothers, who were thought to be in the area. On March 16, 1874, they set out from Osceola to Roscoe, Missouri. After spending the night at the Roscoe House Hotel, they left the day for the home of Theodrick Snuffer, a family friend of the Youngers, some three miles out of town. Posing as cattle buyers, they questioned Snuffer but got nowhere. Little did they know that John and Jim Younger were watching from Snuffer’s attic. When the lawmen left, the two Younger Brothers followed and ordered the three men to halt. Panicked, Pinkerton Agent James Wright spurred his horse and kept on going. However, the other two lawmen, Pinkerton Agent Lull and Daniels, stopped, and within no time, a gunfight ensued. When the smoke cleared, John Younger and Deputy Edwin Daniels were dead, Louis Lull was severely wounded, and Jim Younger received a flesh wound in his hip. Lull was taken to Roscoe for treatment but later died of his wounds.

John Davis is a U.S. deputy marshal in the Indian Territory. On August 1, 1895, he tracked Sam Butler, a wanted murderer and member of the Cook Gang, to the Verdigris River, and when he tried to arrest the fugitive, Butler began to fire his gun. Davis fell mortally wounded but fired one last shot, killing Butler instantly.

Lon Davis –  U.S. Deputy Marshal commissioned in the Muskogee Court in 1898, serving under Marshal Leo Bennett. In 1898, Lon worked with U.S. Deputy Marshals Bud Ledbetter, Dave Adams, Bill Barker, and Harry Adams to close down several gambling operations in Sapulpa, Oklahoma, and arrested the Hughes Gang in Bristow. When the gang of three brothers refused to surrender without a fight, one of them was killed. In May 1905, while Davis was trying to arrest a drunken man named Will Dunn, who was disturbing the peace in Sawyer, Oklahoma, the drunken fool refused, and when the guns began blazing, Dunn was killed. 

Ollie “Big Nose George” Deetz (1850-1889) – Deetz became the marshal of Manhattan, Colorado in May 1887. Manhattan was a gold mining camp in the foothills of the Rocky Mountains in northwestern Larimer County. Like other mining camps of the time, it had a lawless element, and city authorities hired Deetz to “get rid of it.” He seemingly happily complied, killing three men his first night on the job and collecting a $100 bounty on each man. He continued to “rid” the town of its seedier characters, hanging some of them after planting evidence. A year later, he moved northward to Wyoming, and following an alleged bank robbery, he was lynched at Rock Creek on October 5, 1889.

George DeLaughter -U.S. Deputy Marshal commissioned in the Western District at Fort Smith, Arkansas. He rode in a posse led by Columbus Ayers in October 1883, which arrested Johnson Jacks, who had been charged with murdering  U.S. Deputy Marshal Addison Beck.

Cyrus Dennis – U.S. Deputy Marshal commissioned in the Western District Court under Marshal John Carrol out of Fort Smith, Arkansas. He also served as a Seminole Lighthorsemen in the Indian Police for twenty-five years.

Ran Dickerson –  U.S. Deputy Marshal commissioned in the Southern District Court of Indian Territory at Paris, Texas.  In February 1891, Deputies Ran Dickerson, Bill Ritter, Frank LeFlore, and Bill McCall caught up with the Gordon Gang at Brunertown, Seminole Nation, and killed Wash Bruner during a gun battle.

Donald H. “John” Dillingham (1837-1863) – Born in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Dillingham received a good education before making his way west when he grew up. Landing in Bannack, Montana, he was named a deputy under Sheriff Henry Plummer, along with three other men named Charley Forbes, Buck Stinson, and Jack Gallagher. However, these other three deputies were little more than outlaws masquerading as lawmen. Dillingham was an honest man, and when he heard of plans to rob travelers along the roads, he was known to warn the intended victims. As a result, he was shot down in Virginia City, Montana, on June 26, 1863, by Deputies Charley Forbes, Buck Stinson, and another man named Hayes Lyons. Though the killers were arrested and tried in a miners’ court, with several witnesses to the murder, they were acquitted. This incident was just one of many that prompted the organization of vigilante groups in Montana.

Henry W. Dixon –  U.S. Deputy Marshal, commissioned in 1872 in the Western District at Fort Smith, Arkansas, serving under Marshal Logan S. Roots.  He first lived in Scott County, Arkansas while he worked in the Western District Court, but in 1887 was assigned to the Southern District of Indian Territory, located in Paris, Texas, working under Marshal Thomas B. Needles.

William "Billy" Dixon

William “Billy” Dixon

William “Billy” Dixon (1850-1913) – Scout, plainsman, buffalo hunter, and Indian fighter, Dixon fought at the Second Battle of Adobe Walls, was one of the first residents of Hutchinson County, Texas, and served as the county’s first sheriff.

Frederick “Fred” James Dodge (1854-1938)Wells Fargo Detective, constable of Tombstone, Arizona, and Texas cattleman Dodge was in Tombstone during its rowdy boom days.

James M. Dodson (1842-1907) – Dodson was born in Missouri and, by some accounts, had been a member of Quantrill’s Raiders during the Civil War. By the mid-1870s, however, he was in Arizona, working as the Prescott City Marshal. In 1876, he, along with Virgil Earp and Sheriff Ed. F. Bowers, were in a gun battle with two rowdy cowboys in Prescott when Earp killed one of the offenders. Three years later, in December 1879, Dodson, along with Sheriff Joseph R. Walker, Al Seiber, and Thomas Simmons, confronted two stage robbers when a shoot-out erupted. When the smoke cleared, one of the bandits was dead, and the other was arrested.  In April 1882, Dodson killed another fugitive named Joe Banks in the line of duty. Though Prescott, Arizona, had a few accounts of lawlessness, some say that the town never developed into lawless chaos like other popular mining camps of the time, primarily because of Dodson. After retiring as the marshal of Prescott, Dodson moved to Yuma, Arizona, where he worked as a wall guard at the Arizona Penitentiary. His shooting skills proved invaluable on at least one occasion when a prisoner attempted to escape. He spent the last part of his life in Phoenix, Arizona, where he died on May 10, 1907, at the age of 67.

John Doherty – Doherty served as the Mora County, New Mexico Sheriff before he was later murdered. Read his story in Ciaran Conliffe’s article about his Great Grand Uncle – Death of a Sheriff – Murder and Conspiracy in the Old West.

Cornelius Donahue Hanging Tree

Cornelius Donahue Hanging Tree

Leslie Dow (18??-1897) – A gunfighter and a lawman, Dow killed Zack Light in a gunfight in the late 1880s. He later became Eddy County, New Mexico sheriff on November 27, 1896. He was killed the next April by the former sheriff, Dave Kemp.

William Downing – Served as a Deputy sheriff in Willcox, Arizona, under Burt” Alvord in the late 1890s. Later, when Alvord turned outlaw, Downing allowed him to escape.

E.L.M Drake (18??-1892)U.S. Deputy Marshal in Oklahoma Territory. On May 25, 1892, Drake was looking for two horse thieves, William Miller and William Hostetter. When he tracked them to the Deep Fork Creek near Sapulpa, Oklahoma, and attempted to serve the warrant, the two pulled their guns and began firing. Drake’s horse was killed, and he took a shot in the side and a thigh. However, he returned fire, killing both of the outlaws. Though some newspapers of the time reported that Drake had died of his wounds, other records indicated that he was re-commissioned as a U.S. Deputy Marshal in 1894.

Charles N. Dugger – (18??-1896) – A U.S. Deputy Marshal in Oklahoma Territory, Dugger was killed in the line of duty on June 20, 1896. A lawman for some 20 years, Dugger was shot on August 31, 1890, in southern Oklahoma Territory but survived to telegraph for assistance. Several years later, however, he would not be so fortunate. On June 20, 1896, while riding with posseman Joe Boyle, the pair tried to arrest three whiskey peddlers in the Osage Nation. However, the outlaws resisted, killing both officers.

John Riley Duncan (1850-1911) – Dallas police officer, detective, and Texas Ranger, most noteworthy in the capture of John Wesley Hardin.

Perry DuVal (18?-1873) – A U.S. Deputy Marshal in Indian Territory, DuVal, along with U.S. Deputy Marshals Will Ayers and James Wilkerson, were escorting several prisoners from Indian Territory to Fort Smith, Arkansas on November 2, 1873. While the marshals and prisoners settled down for the night northwest of Muskogee, Oklahoma, one of the prisoners, a man named John Billy, somehow got out of his handcuffs, grabbed Marshal Duval’s weapon, and shot him in the head. He then shot Marshals Ayers and Wilkerson, though both survived. John Billy was hanged for the murder at Fort Smith, Arkansas on April 3, 1874.


© Kathy Alexander/Legends of America, February 2024.

Also See:

Adventures in the American West

Lawmen of the Old West

Old West Photo Galleries

Who’s Who in American History

Lawman Summaries (name begins with) A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z