Pawnee Bill – Another Wild West Showman

Gordon W. "Pawnee Bill" Lillie

Gordon W. “Pawnee Bill” Lillie

One of the many who exemplified the “Wild West” was Gordon W. “Pawnee Bill” Lillie. Gordon was the oldest of four children born to Susan and Newton Lillie in Bloomington, Illinois, on February 14, 1860. His father owned and operated a flour mill and was considered one of the prosperous citizens of Bloomington. When he was old enough, Gordon worked for his father but was fascinated with the Old West and spent his free time reading dime novels about the Old West and Buffalo Bill Cody.

When the flour mill burned down in the 1870s, the family moved to Wellington, Kansas, where they had relatives. The family began to farm and soon set up another flour mill.

When the Pawnee Indians were being moved from their homeland in Nebraska to Indian Territory, they made a winter camp near Wellington. The boy soon spent many hours with them, learning their skills and language. While there, he also made a long-time friend, a tribal elder, Blue Hawk.

When he was 15, Gordon joined a cattle drive in Wichita, Kansas. He then moved south to Indian Territory to visit his friend, Blue Hawk. There, he lived near the Pawnee reservation and got a job in a rock quarry, but he spent his free time with the Pawnee, who allowed him to participate in their annual buffalo hunt. He joined Trapper Tom McCain’s fur trading company for a short time, then returned to the Pawnee. In 1879, he became a Pawnee teacher and served as an interpreter and secretary to Major Bowman, the Indian agent. During this time, Gordon became known as Pawnee Bill – a name the Pawnee Indians gave him.

In 1883, Gordon was delighted when the Pawnee Agency received a letter from Buffalo Bill asking for several Indians to travel with his newly organized Wild West Show. Six of the Pawnee, along with Gordon Lillie, quickly volunteered.

Pawnee Bill and his wife, May

Pawnee Bill and his wife, May

Gordon would work as both an interpreter and a performer. They soon set off traveling the nation, and while Pawnee Bill was in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, he met May Manning, a 15-year-old Quaker girl watching the parade. The pair maintained a long-distance courtship for the next two years before marrying in 1886.

May’s family soon started to talk Gordon into starting his own show, and, liking the idea, he recruited backers and organized the “Pawnee Bill Wild West Show” in 1888. Practicing with him, his wife May performed as “Champion Girl Horseback Shot of the West.” Unfortunately, the production went broke after only one season.

Undaunted, Pawnee Bill reorganized as “Pawnee Bill’s Historical Wild West Indian Museum and Encampment Show.” This time, it was successful, so much so that he took his show to Europe. However, it was a mistake – the show went bankrupt while there.

Regrouping once again, the show then toured Holland and France, entertaining royalty. They then returned to the United States and were once again successful.

In 1902 Pawnee Bill established the Buffalo Ranch on land he purchased from Blue Hawk. Later, he traveled to Washington, D.C., to promote a congressional bill to develop a wildlife refuge.

He also expanded his show and became serious competition for Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show. In 1907 Gordon hired performers from various backgrounds, including Mexican cowboys, Pawnee and Sioux scouts, Chinese and Japanese performers, and Arab jugglers. He renamed the production “Pawnee Bill’s Wild West and Great Far East Show.”

Pawnee Bill Wild West Show, 1898, Strobridge Litho. Co

Pawnee Bill Wild West Show, 1898, Strobridge Litho. Co.

At about the same time, Buffalo Bill’s show was starting to suffer financially, and in 1908, Pawnee Bill purchased a one-third interest in the production. Soon, Gordon bought the remaining interest in the show but retained Buffalo Bill as a partner.

The two traveled together as the “Two Bill’s Show” until 1913, when the venture again went bankrupt. It was billed as one of the entertainment triumphs of the ages and traveled worldwide, entertaining audiences with realistic and fantasy views of the Old West. The show closed in Denver, Colorado, in 1913 after touring for five seasons.

Gordon and May built their dream home on Blue Hawk Peak and moved into the dwelling in 1910. May became manager of the Buffalo Ranch while Gordon traveled with Buffalo Bill. In 1916 they adopted a child and named him Billy. During this time, Gordon also began diversifying his investments, opening an oil refinery in Yale, Oklahoma, raising cattle, and starting a movie production company on his ranch. Tragically, their adopted son Billy died in an accident when he was eight.

In 1930 Pawnee Bill built and operated “Pawnee Bill’s Old Town,” two miles west of his ranch, a tourist attraction featuring log cabins, tepees, saloons, gunfights, and other attractions from the Old West. Six years later, May died in an automobile accident. Gordon died in 1942. He was 81.

Unfortunately, Old Town burned to the ground in 1944, along with some of the finest objects of Indian art and artifacts of the Old West.

Pawnee Bill’s arts and crafts style home, filled with his original furnishings and collections, has become Pawnee Bill’s Ranch and Museum in Pawnee, Oklahoma. The museum also features the first log cabin that housed Bill and May when they first purchased the ranch, the three-story stone barn that Bill built in 1926 to house his animals, an observation tower Bill utilized to look out over his ranchlands, and other outbuildings.

Entrance to Pawnee Bill Ranch in Oklahoma.

Ranch Arena buildings at Pawnee Bill Ranch in Oklahoma.

The ranch also maintains one of the finest herds of bison in the world and a herd of longhorn cattle. Pawnee, Oklahoma, is about 55 miles west of Tulsa on U.S. 64. The Ranch is at the top of the hill just west of the town.

A longhorn stares us down at the Pawnee Bill Ranch in Oklahoma.

You can drive through the area with Longhorns and Buffalo at Pawnee Bill Ranch; stay in your vehicle.

Contact Information:

Pawnee Bill Ranch and Museum
PO Box 493
Pawnee, Oklahoma 74058

© Kathy Alexander/Legends of America, updated November 2022.

Also See:

Buffalo Bill Cody

Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show

Pawnee Tribe

Old West (main page)

Entertainment Photo Print Gallery