Pony Deal – Outlaw & Gunfighter of the Southwest



Charles T. Ray, also known as Pony Deal or Diehl, was an outlaw and gunfighter in the American West.

Though not nearly so well known as other gunfighters in history, Ray, who is far better known in history as “Pony Deal,” rode with, met, and fought with some of the most infamous characters of the West, including names such as Billy the Kid, Wyatt Earp, Ike Clanton, and numerous others.

Hailing from Rock Island, Illinois, Ray first appears in history, going by the name of Pony Deal, as a member of the John Kinney Gang in New Mexico in the 1870s. The gang members were successful cattle rustlers and hired gunmen who operated in Dona Ana County. On December 31, 1875, Deal, along with gang leader John Kinney, Jesse Evans, and Jim McDaniels, entered a saloon in Las Cruces, New Mexico, where they became involved in a brawl with US Cavalry soldiers from Fort Stanton. When the outlaws lost the fight, they were thrown out of the saloon, but the vengeful men couldn’t let it go. They soon returned to the saloon and opened fire through the windows, killing two soldiers and a civilian and wounding two more soldiers and another bystander.

Billy the Kid

Billy the Kid

Deal rode with the Kinney Gang through 1875, and in early 1876, he left the gang to join Jesse Evans, who had departed to start his own gang. This gang was involved in cattle rustling and armed robbery, and for a while, Billy the Kid rode with the gang. They were soon enlisted by the MurphyDolan faction in their feud with John H. Tunstall in Lincoln, New Mexico. At this time, Billy the Kid quit the gang, as he was a friend of Tunstall. After the killing of John Tunstall by the Evans Gang, it sparked the Lincoln County War, during which Evans and his gang would match up against their former partner Billy the Kid and his “Regulators.” After the end of the Lincoln County War, Pony Deal drifted on to Tombstone, Arizona, where he met and became associated with Ike Clanton, Billy Clanton,  Frank McLaury, Tom McLaury, Johnny Ringo, and “Curly Bill” Brocius, becoming part of the Cowboy Faction.

Deal was involved in various events that led up to the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral. He was suspected of being involved in numerous robberies and cattle rustling, as well as in the theft of US Army mules alongside Sherman McMasters. After the assassination attempt on Virgil Earp, in which Virgil lost the use of one arm, the Earps suspected Ike Clanton, Phin Clanton, and Pony Deal in the murder attempt. He was sought after by Wyatt Earp during the Earp Vendetta Ride but wasn’t found.

Later, he would claim to have killed John O’Rourke in 1882 after O’Rourke allegedly killed his friend, Johnny Ringo. That same year, he was running from the law when a warrant was issued for his arrest relating to a stagecoach robbery. Again, he avoided capture. He then drifted around, spending some time in El Paso, Texas and rustling cattle again for John Kinney. He was finally captured and sentenced to five years in prison in Santa Fe, New Mexico. He escaped in February 1885 but was free for only four days before being recaptured. Returned to prison, he was released in March 1887, after which time he disappeared from history, although some accounts say that he was killed in a gunfight.

© Kathy Alexander/Legends of America, updated November 2022.

Also See:

Earp Vendetta Ride

Complete List of Old West Gunfighters

New Mexico’s Lincoln County War

Wyatt Earp – Frontier Lawman