Borger – Rip Roaring “Booger Town”

Borger – Boomtown by Thomas Hart Benton.

The largest city in Hutchinson County, Texas, Borger got its start during the Oil Boom of the 1920s. The first oil well in the area was drilled on May 2, 1921, on the 6666 Ranch, and though the strike was of poor quality, it spawned more drilling in Texas Panhandle. Soon a number of successful wells were producing in the Borger area. In January 1926, Asa Phillip “Ace” Borger, a townsite developer, who had earlier established two other oil boomtowns — Slick and Cromwell, Oklahoma, came to the area to personally check out the reports of the oil boom.

Before long, Borger and John R. Miller, an attorney and old friend from the Oklahoma boomtowns, purchased 240 acres from rancher John Frank Weatherly, for $50 per acre. Borger then obtained a grant to organize the Borger Townsite Company, with capital stock of $10,000 divided into 100 shares of $100 each. The Townsite Company was comprised of Ace Borger, John R. Miller, and C. C. Horton of the Gulf Oil Company.

Lot sales began on March 8, 1926, and by the end of the first day, the Borger Townsite Company had grossed between $60,000 and $100,000. A post office was opened the next month on April 13th with Lawrence E. Brain as the first postmaster. Over the next months, the Borger Town Company took out full-page ads in area papers promoting settlement in the fledgling town and within a few months’ time, the boomtown had swelled to a population of 45,000, most lured by sensational advertising and “black gold”. Though the population had boomed, many of these new “residents” were transient and lived in tents and shacks.

After six months, Ace Borger sold out his interest in the Borger Townsite Company for more than a million dollars. But, he was not nearly done with development of the town or the area. In October 1926, the charter incorporating the city of Borger was adopted, and Ace Borger’s partner, John R. Miller was elected mayor. By that time, the Panhandle and Santa Fe Railroad had completed a spur line to Borger, a school district had been established, a newspaper — the Hutchinson County Herald (now the Borger News-Herald) had started publication and Ace Borger had established a lumberyard. Along Borger’s three-mile-long Main Street, also stood the town’s first hamburger stand, established by J.D. Williams, as well as a hotel and a jail. Telephone service and steam-generated electricity were available by the end of of the year. Before wells were drilled, drinking water was provided in tank wagons.

Area ranchers John R. Weatherly and James A. Whittenburg also hoped to cash in on the boom, by establishing three rival townsites, Isom, Dixon Creek, and Whittenburg, all next to that of Borger. Later Isom and Dixon Creek were incorporated into the Borger city limits. The town of Whittenburg was merged with the town of Pantex and became Phillips.

In the months that followed, oilmen, roughnecks, prospectors, panhandlers, and fortune seekers flooded the oil boomtown and along with them came a number of shadier elements including cardsharks, prostitutes, bootleggers and drug dealers. The city became known as “Booger Town” as it attracted fugitives from the law and some of the toughest hoodlums in the Southwest — people such as Yellow Young, Ray Terill, Spider Gibson, Wireline Yerkey, and Waltine. J. “Shine” Popejoy, who was known as the “King of Texas Bootleggers”.

Borger area Oil Well, 1920’s.

Making matters worse, the town government soon fell under control of an organized crime syndicate led by Mayor John Miller’s shady associate, Richard “Two-Gun Dick” Herwig, a man who was reportedly under indictment for murder in Cromwell, Oklahoma. Herwig, the town’s designated Chief Law Enforcement Officer, brought with him a number of felonious friends to staff his city marshal force and “police” the flourishing town. However, their primary responsibility seems to have been collecting fees from bootleggers and weekly fines from prostitutes.

Herwig and his men sanctioned and supervised wide-open saloons in defiance of Prohibition while supplying the illegal barrooms their own lines of bootlegged alcohol and beer, as well as narcotics. Dixon Street (now Tenth Street) was the center of all the “fun” — housing brothels, dance halls, speakeasies, and gambling dens. Here, some 2,000 prostitutes were said to have practiced their profession, with each paying a weekly “fine” of $18 to stay in business. In addition to the fines and illegal products provided to the saloons, the city marshals also made money by demanding on-the-spot collections of arbitrary fines from other businesses and ordinary citizens as well as the buying and selling of stolen cars. Murder and robbery became an everyday occurrence, as the “marshals” had no time for the protection of everyday citizens.

Borger 90 days old

In the summer of 1926, two deputy sheriffs were shot down on a Borger street by one of the many fugitives, who had bought sanctuary from Herwig. Like all homicides at this time, this double murder went unpunished and provoked a crackdown by state and federal authorities. In October 1926, the town was infiltrated with Prohibition and narcotic agents, U.S. Marshals, and Texas Rangers.

Some 20 bars and gambling dens were padlocked, the illegal liquor was confiscated, and the gaming equipment was destroyed. Fifty violators were arrested and hundreds more were herded into a domino hall by shotgun-toting federal marshals and strongly advised to relocate. The Federal agents then departed leaving the Rangers to police Borger and dispose of the prisoners, who were soon loaded into trucks and driven to jail in Amarillo. Numerous other “undesirables” were ordered to leave town. By the end of the month, the Texas Rangers declared Borger to be “100% better.” But, their proclamation was far too premature.

Within three months, the criminals were right back in business, at which time Borger was again teeming with slot machines, brothels and more than 20 gambling joints. In the meantime, Sheriff Joe Ownbey was taking no actions and was allegedly receiving frequent payoffs. In late March, gangsters killed a city policeman and on April 1, two of Ownbey’s deputies. By the spring of 1927, a new governor was in place in the Texas capitol, and acting on petitions and investigative reports, Governor Daniel J. Moody sent another detachment of Texas Rangers, under Captains Francis Augustus Hamer and Thomas R. Hickman, to once again rein in the town.

John A. Holmes

Although the Rangers proved a stabilizing force and compelled many undesirables to once again, leave town, Borger’s wave of crime and violence would continue intermittently into the early 1930s. In the meantime, Texas Governor Moody appointed a new District Attorney to the area in 1928. John A. Holmes was tasked with investigating and prosecuting the many criminals who had infested Borger and the surrounding oil fields. Though Holmes was threatened by gangsters on a number of occasions, he relentlessly continued his probe of crime and corruption in Borger. Just as Holmes was making final preparations to appear before the Hutchinson County grand jury at Stinnett, he was shot down by an unknown assassin on September 13, 1929.

The Holmes slaying was the last straw for Governor Moody. Forty-eight hours after the murder, the Texas Rangers were back in Borger. Two weeks later, the Texas Rangers were joined by the 56th Cavalry of the Texas National Guard. At about 8:30 a.m. on Monday, September 30th, a train of baggage cars, three Pullmans, and freighters pulled into Borger, where ten Texas Rangers were already in place. On that day, martial law was declared for Hutchinson County and the Texas Rangers and the National Guard were tasked by ridding the lawless town and the surrounding area of its criminal elements once and for all. Led by General Jacob F. Wolters, who had earlier been in charge of another city shut down by martial law, the troops disembarked, having an immediate effect on the town. Later, General Wolters would write:

In every situation where military authority is used to aid the civil power things occur that have either a good or a bad psychological effect. They are, in common parlance, the ‘breaks’ of the game. We had just such a break at Borger. Within one minute after the troops had detrained, a drunk man approached one of the guards. He was promptly put under arrest. This occurrence, in the presence of spectators, had a good psychological effect, however minor the incident was.”

Detachments of officers and soldiers were immediately sent to city hall where Wolter’s provost marshal, Colonel Louis S. Davidson, took possession and disarmed all the local lawmen. Another detail drove to Stinnett, the county seat, and removed Sheriff Joe Ownbey and disarmed all of the sheriffs’ department personnel. MPs were stationed at all city street intersections in Borger and patrols were sent throughout the city. Members of the police force and constables were disarmed, their uniforms and badges were taken away. City offices and all records, books, and papers of the city of Borger fell under the authority of Provost Marshal. Within hours of his arrival, General Wolters had complete control of the city and county. “Sundown” orders were issued to every person in the city, man and woman alike, and all “undesirables” were ordered to get out of town immediately.

A military court of inquiry was quickly established and over the next days and weeks, scores of witnesses gave testimony which officials hoped would result in the conviction of alleged leaders in the county’s underworld. By October 10, there were 17 members of the organized criminal ring behind bars. These included Dick Herwig and his henchmen.

On October 5th a committee of citizens called on General Wolters to ask what he required to end martial law. He responded by advising the citizens that he would demand the resignation of the sheriff and all his deputies, the two constables and their deputies, the mayor, the city commission, and all members of the police department. Mayor Glen Pace and Sheriff Joe Ownbey tried some stalling tactics, but, after deliberations involving the district judge and grand jury, all gave in and resigned by mid-October.

Texas Rangers in Borger

In the meantime, the Texas Rangers were busy closing every illegal still and saloon, confiscating whiskey and beer, and making arrests. Soldiers were searching for any weapons, and raids were conducted 24 hours a day. Finally, on October 18th, Governor Moody withdrew the military from Borger, and 11 days later, he formally lifted martial law. He granted Texas Ranger, Charles O. Moore a leave of absence for a year to serve as Hutchinson County Sheriff; another ranger would serve as the Chief of Police, and a new District Attorney was appointed.

Sam Jones, a former deputy constable of Borger, and Jim Hodges, a Borger boilermaker, were both indicted for murder in the death of John A. Holmes. They also were charged with bootlegging, and Jones faced a federal count of conspiracy to violate the National Prohibition Act. Jones was released from jail on bonds totaling $20,000, but he and Hodges never were brought to trial on the murder charges. On Oct. 26, 1945, the state dismissed the murder charges “because in the opinion of the state’s attorney, the evidence is insufficient to warrant the probability of a conviction.” The case was never solved.

Borger, Texas Heydays

Borger did finally settle down after this latest episode of state involvement. However, there would one more major criminal event — the killing of town founder and developer Ace Borger on August 31, 1934. Ace had long been extremely generous with many of his friends and acquaintances while being very tight with others. This often caused hard feelings with some folks. In June 1930, Ace established the Borger State Bank, with himself as president and his son as vice president. Before the year was even over, the bank failed, causing a panic among local businessmen and small depositors.

This raised the ire of those who didn’t like him, especially a man named Arthur Huey, who was the Hutchinson County Treasurer. Ace Borger was later convicted of receiving deposits in the insolvent bank and assessed a two-year prison term. However, he remained free as the judgment was on appeal.

Sometime later, Hutchinson County Treasurer, Arthur Huey was jailed for embezzlement and asked the normally generous Ace Borger to help bail him out. When Borger refused, Huey made threats against his life. Huey was able to raise the bail without Borger’s help and on August 31, 1934, when Borger was getting his mail at the city post office, Huey shouted obscenities at Borger and shot him five times with a Colt .45. He then took Borger’s own .44 and fired four more into him. An innocent bystander was also hit by a shot and died five days later. Amazingly, Huey was acquitted for the murder claiming self-defense. Later; however, Arthur Huey was sent to prison for embezzlement of county funds.

The 1927 El Reno Ice House is one of the oldest buildings in Borger, Texas,. Kathy Weiser-Alexander, July, 2013.

The decade of the 1930s was a mixture of boom and depression for Borger as well as the rest of Hutchinson County. The nation was going through the Great Depression, and the great storms of the Dust Bowl had begun. With ten Carbon black plants in the area, volumes of black soot was added to the Dust Bowl storms, covering the town in layers of dark grime. Many an “Okie” migrant, fleeing from their devastated farms, found jobs in the oilfields and plants. During World War II, synthetic rubber and other petroleum products became important in the Borger area. Borger’s population was listed at 14,000 in 1943.

By the 1960s the Borger area was one of the largest producers of oil, carbon black, and petrochemicals and supplies in the state. The creation of nearby Lake Meredith also added to the town’s economy as an important recreational area. In 1960, Borger’s population was 20,911, but, ten years later had dropped to 14,195. Today, Borger is called home to some 13,000 people an remains an important shipping point for agricultural produce as well as continuing to manufacture numerous petroleum products.

The Hutchinson County Museum, also known as Boomtown Revisited, houses artifacts of the county’s pioneer past. Borger is located at the junction of State highways 136, 152, and 207, in south-central Hutchinson County.

Boomtown Revisited Museum in Borger, Texas tells the story of its boomtown history, Kathy Weiser-Alexander, July 2013.

More Information:
City of Borger
600 North Main Street
PO Box 5250
Borger, Texas 79008-5250
806-273-0900

© Kathy Weiser-Alexander, Legends of America, updated August 2020,

Sources:

City of Borger

History of Hutchinson County, Texas: 104 years, 1876-1980

Phillips Highschool Alumni Association

Texas Escapes

Texas State Historical Association

Wikipedia

Also See:

Asa Phillip “Ace” Borger – Father of a Wicked City

Hutchinson County – Panhandle Frontier

 

1 thought on “Borger – Rip Roaring “Booger Town””

  1. I volunteered at the Hutchinson County Museum and they placed me in the library to organize the books and donated materials and manuscripts. I found a handwritten biography from a man who described himself as a criminal, living in the early days in Borger. He wrote that he knew who killed John Holmes and at the end of the manuscript he identifies the name of the man. I gave the manuscript to the Director of the Museum and showed him the place where the writer identifies the proposed killer. I’m unsure what happened to the manuscript after I gave it to the Director.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *