by Charles A. Eastman, 1918
Among the Sioux chiefs of the “transition period,” only one was shrewd enough to read coming events in their true light. It is said of Spotted Tail that he was rather a slow-moving boy, preferring in their various games and mimic battles to play the role of councilor, to plan and assign to the others their parts in the fray. This he did so cleverly that he soon became a leader among his youthful contemporaries, and withal he was apt at mimicry and impersonation so that the other boys were accustomed to say of him, “He has his grandfather’s wit and the wisdom of his grandmother!”
Spotted Tail was an orphan, reared by his grandparents, and compelled to shift for himself at an early age. Thus, he was somewhat at a disadvantage among the other boys, yet even this fact may have helped develop his courage and ingenuity.
One minor incident of his young life, occurring at about his tenth year, is characteristic of the man. Amid a game, two boys became involved in a dispute which promised to be a serious one, as both drew knives. The young Spotted Tail instantly began to cry, “The Shoshone are upon us! To arms! to arms!” The other boys joined in the war-whoop. This distracted the attention of the combatants and ended the affair.
Upon the whole, his boyhood is not so well remembered as is that of most of his leading contemporaries, probably because he had no parents to bring him frequently before the people, as was the custom with the wellborn, whose every step in their progress toward manhood was publicly announced at a feast given in their honor. However, it is known that he began at an early age to carve out a position for himself. Personal qualities alone tell among our people, and the youthful Spotted Tail gained at every turn. At the age of seventeen, he had become a sure shot and a clever hunter, but, above all, he had already shown that he possessed a superior mind. He had come into contact with white people at the various trading posts. According to his own story, he had carefully studied the white man’s habits and modes of thought, especially of his peculiar trait of the economy and intense desire to accumulate property. He was accustomed to watching closely and listening attentively whenever any of this strange race had dealings with his people. When a council was held, and the other young men stood at a distance with their robes over their faces to avoid recognition, Spotted Tail always put himself in a position to hear all that was said on either side and weighed all the arguments in his mind.
When he first went upon the warpath, it appears that he was, if anything, overzealous to establish himself in the eye of his people. It was especially hard for him to gain an assured position among the Brules, with whom he lived, both because he was an orphan and his father had been of another band. Yet, it was not long before he achieved his ambition, though he received several ugly wounds. In a battle with the Ute, he first notably served his people and their cause.
The Utes were the attacking party and far outnumbered the Sioux on this occasion. Many of their bravest young men had fallen, and the Brule were face to face with utter destruction, when Spotted Tail, with a handful of daring horsemen, dodged around the enemy’s flank and fell upon them from the rear with so much spirit that they supposed that strong reinforcements had arrived, and retreated in confusion. The Sioux pursued on horseback, and the noted chief Two Strike gained his historical name in this pursuit. But the top honors of the fight belonged to Spotted Tail. The old chiefs, Conquering Bear, and the rest thanked him and made him a war chief.
It had been the firm belief of Spotted Tail that it was unwise to allow the white man so much freedom in our country long before the older chiefs saw any harm in it. After the opening of the Oregon Trail, he, above all the others, was watchful of the conduct of the Americans as they journeyed toward the setting sun. More than once, he remarked in council that these white men were not like the French and the Spanish, with whom our old chiefs had been used to deal. He was not fully satisfied with the agreement with General Harney, but as a young warrior who had only just gained his position in the council, he could not force his views upon the older men.
No sooner had the Oregon Trail been secured from the Sioux than Fort Laramie and other frontier posts were strengthened, and the soldiers became more insolent and overbearing than ever. It was soon discovered that the whites were prepared to violate most of the articles of their treaty as the Indians understood it. At this time, the presence of many Mormon emigrants on their way to the settlements in Utah and Wyoming added to the perils of the situation, as they constantly maneuvered for purposes of their own to bring about a clash between the soldiers and the Indians. Every summer, storm clouds were blowing between these two – clouds usually taking their rise in some affair of the travelers along the trail.
In 1854 an event that has already been described snapped the last link of friendship between the races.
By this time, Spotted Tail had proved his courage abroad and at home. He had fought a duel with one of the lesser chiefs, by whom he was attacked. He killed his opponent with an arrow, but he received a blow from a battle-ax upon his head which brought him senseless to the ground. He was left for dead but fortunately revived just as the men were preparing his body for burial.
The Brules sustained him in this quarrel, as he had acted in self-defense, and for a few years, he led them in bloody raids against the whites along the historic trail. He ambushed many stagecoaches and emigrant trains and was responsible for waylaying the Kincaid coach with twenty thousand dollars. This relentless harrying of travelers soon brought General Harney to the Brule Sioux to demand explanations and reparation.
The old chiefs of the Brules now appealed to Spotted Tail and his young warriors not to bring any general calamity upon the tribe. To the surprise of all, Spotted Tail declared that he would give himself up. He said that he had defended the rights of his people to the best of his ability, that he had avenged the blood of their chief, Conquering Bear, and that he was not afraid to accept the consequences. He therefore voluntarily surrendered to General Harney, and two of his lieutenants, Red Leaf and Old Woman, followed his example.
Thus Spotted Tail played an essential part at the very outset of those events which were soon to overthrow the free life of his people. I do not know how far he foresaw what was to follow. Still, whether conceived or not, his surrender was a masterstroke, winning for him not only the admiration of his people but also the confidence and respect of the military.
Thus suddenly, he found himself in prison, a hostage for the good behavior of his followers. There were many rumors about the punishment reserved for him, but luckily for Spotted Tail, the promises of General Harney to the Brule chiefs in respect to him were faithfully kept. One of his fellow prisoners committed suicide, but the other held out bravely for the two-year term of his imprisonment. During the second year, it was well understood that neither of the men sought to escape, and they were given much freedom. It was fine schooling for Spotted Tail, that tireless observer of the ways of the white man! It is a fact that his engaging personal qualities won him kindness and sympathy at the fort before the time came for his release.
One day some Indian horse thieves of another tribe stampeded the horses and mules belonging to the garrison. Spotted Tail asked permission from the commanding officer to accompany the pursuers. That officer, trusting in honor of a Sioux brave, gave him a fast horse and a good carbine and said: “I depend upon you to guide my soldiers so that they may overtake the thieves and recapture the horses!”
The soldiers recaptured the horses without any loss, but Spotted Tail followed the Indians. Everybody agreed that he would never turn up when they returned to the fort without him. However, the next day he did “turn up” with the scalp of one of the marauders! Soon after, he was returned to his people, who honored him by making him the successor of the old chief, Conquering Bear, whose blood he had avenged, for which act he had taken upon himself the full responsibility. He had made good use of his two years at the fort and completed his civilization studies to his satisfaction. From then on, he was desirous of reconciling the Indian and the white man, thoroughly understanding the uselessness of opposition. Accordingly, he was constantly communicating with the military, but the other chiefs did not understand his views and seemed suspicious of his motives.
In 1860-1864 the Southern Cheyenne and Comanche were at war with the whites, and some of the Brule and Ogallala, their neighbors and intimates, were suspected of complicity with the hostiles. Doubtless, a few of their young men may have been involved; at any rate, Thunder Bear and Two Face, together with a few others roving with the warring tribes, purchased two captive white women and brought them to Fort Laramie. It was reported at the post that these two men had maltreated the women while under their care.
Of course, the commander demanded of Spotted Tail, then head chief, that he give up the guilty ones, and accordingly, he had the two men arrested and delivered to the fort. There was an outcry among his people, but he argued that if the charges were accurate, the men deserved punishment, and if false, they should be tried and cleared by the process of law. The Indians never quite knew what evidence was produced at the court-martial, but at all events, the two men were hanged, and as they had many influential connections, their relatives lost no time in fomenting trouble.
The Sioux were then camping close by the fort, and it was midwinter, which facts held them in check for a month or two; but as soon as spring came, they removed their camp across the river and rose in rebellion. A pitched battle was fought, in which the soldiers got the worst of it. Even the associate chief, Big Mouth, was against Spotted Tail, who was practically forced against his will and judgment to take up arms once more.
At this juncture came the sudden and bloody uprising among the Minnesota Sioux in the east. Sitting Bull’s campaign in the north had begun in earnest, while the Southern Cheyenne, Comanche, and Kiowa were all upon the warpath to the south. Spotted Tail, at about this time seems to have conceived the idea of uniting all the Rocky Mountain Indians in a great confederacy. He once said: “Our cause is as a child’s cause, in comparison with the power of the white man, unless we can stop quarreling among ourselves and unite our energies for the common good.”
But old-time antagonisms were too strong, and he was probably held back also by his consciousness that the Indians called him “the white man’s friend” while the military still had some faith in him which he did not care to lose. He was undoubtedly one of the brainiest and most brilliant Sioux ever. While he could not help being, to a large extent, in sympathy with the feeling of his race against the invader, yet he alone foresaw the inevitable outcome. The problem as it presented itself to him was simply this: “What is the best policy to pursue in the existing situation?”
Here is his speech as it has been given to me, delivered at the great council on the Powder River, just before the attack on Fort Phil Kearny, Wyoming. We can imagine that he threw all his remarkable tact and personal magnetism into this last effort at conciliation.
“Hay, hay, hay! Alas, alas!’ Thus speaks the old man when he knows that his former vigor and freedom are gone from him forever. So we may exclaim today, Alas! There is a time appointed to all things. Think for a moment how many multitudes of the animal tribes we have destroyed! Look upon the snow that appears today — tomorrow, it is water! Listen to the dirge of the dry leaves that were green and vigorous but a few moons before! We are a part of this life, and it seems that our time has come.
Yet note how the decay of one nation invigorates another. This strange white man — consider him, his gifts are manifold! His tireless brain, and his busy hand do wonders for his race. Those things which we despise he holds as treasures, yet he is so great and so flourishing that there must be some virtue and truth in his philosophy. I wish to say to you, my friends: Be not moved alone by heated arguments and thoughts of revenge! These are for the young. We are young no longer; let us think well and give counsel as old men!”
These words were greeted with an ominous silence. Not even the customary “How!” of assent followed the speech. Sitting Bull immediately got up and replied in the celebrated harangue, which will be introduced under his own name in another chapter. The situation was critical for Spotted Tail — the only man present to advocate submission to the stronger race whose ultimate supremacy he recognized as certain. The decision to attack Fort Phil Kearny was unanimous without him, and to hold his position among his tribesmen, he joined in the charge. Several bullets passed through his war bonnet, and he was slightly wounded.
When the commission of 1867-1868 was sent out to negotiate with the Sioux, Spotted Tail was ready to meet them and eager to obtain the very best terms he could for his people. He often puzzled and embarrassed them by his remarkable speeches, the pointed questions, and his telling allusions to former negotiations. Meanwhile, Red Cloud would not come into the council until after several deputations of Indians had been sent to him, and Sitting Bull did not come at all.
The famous treaty was signed, and from this time on, Spotted Tail never again took up arms against the whites. On the contrary, it was mainly attributed to his influence that the hostiles were subdued much sooner than expected. He came into the reservation with his band, urged his young men to enlist as government scouts, and assisted materially in all negotiations. The hostile chiefs no longer influenced his action. As soon as they had all been brought under military control, General Crook named Spotted Tail head chief of the Sioux, thus humiliating Red Cloud and arousing jealousy and ill-feeling among the Ogallala. To avoid trouble, he prudently separated himself from the other bands and moved to the new agency on Beaver Creek (Fort Sheridan, Nebraska) called “Spotted Tail Agency.”
Just before the daring war leader, Crazy Horse, surrendered to the military, he went down to the agency. He roundly rebuked Spotted Tail for signing away the freedom of his people. From the point of view of the irreconcilables, the diplomatic chief was a “trimmer” and a traitor; and many of the Sioux have tried to implicate him in the conspiracy against Crazy Horse that led to his assassination, but I hold that the facts do not bear out this charge.
The name Spotted Tail was prominently before the people during the rest of his life. An obscure orphan, he had achieved distinction by his bravery and sagacity; but he copied the white politician too closely after entering the reservation. He became a good manipulator and was made conceited and overbearing by the attentions of the military and the general public. Furthermore, there was an old feud in his immediate band, which affected him closely. Against him for many years were the followers of Big Mouth, whom he had killed in a duel, and a party led by a son and a nephew of the old chief, Conquering Bear, whom Spotted Tail had succeeded at his death. These two men had hoped that one of them might obtain the succession.
Crow Dog, the nephew of Conquering Bear, more than once taunted Spotted Tail with the fact that he was chief not by the will of the tribe but by the help of the white soldiers and told him that he would “keep a bullet for him” in case he ever disgraced his high position. Thus retribution lay in wait for him while at the height of his fame. Several high-handed actions of his at this time, including his elopement with another man’s wife, increased his unpopularity with a significant element of his tribe. On the eve of the chief’s departure for Washington to negotiate (or so they suspected) for the sale of more of their land, Crow Dog took up his gun and fulfilled his threat, regarding himself, and regarded by his supporters, not as a murderer, but as an executioner.
Such was the end of the man who may justly be called the Pontiac of the west. He possessed a remarkable mind and extraordinary foresight for an untutored savage. Yet, he is the only one of our great men to be remembered with more honor by the white man, perhaps, than by his people.
About the Author: Excerpted from the book Indian Heroes and Great Chieftains, by Charles A. Eastman, 1918. Charles A. Eastman earned a medical degree from Boston University School of Medicine in 1890 and then began working for the Office of Indian Affairs later that year. He worked at the Pine Ridge Agency, South Dakota, and was an eyewitness to both events leading up to and following the Wounded Knee Massacre of December 29, 1890. Himself part- Sioux, he knew many of the people about whom he wrote.