Joaquin Murrieta – Patriot or Desperado?

Joaquin Murrieta

Joaquin Murrieta

Depending on a California pioneer’s point of view in the mid 19th century, Joaquin Murrieta was described by some as a Mexican Patriot, while others would say he was nothing but a vicious desperado.

Thought to have been born in either Alamos, Sonora, Mexico or Quillota, Chile in 1829; Joaquin traveled with his older brother, Carlos and his wife, Rosita, to California in 1850 to seek his fortune in the gold fields. The three immigrants soon set up a small farm and the brothers began to work a claim near Hangtown. However, in the same year as their arrival, a Foreign Miners Tax was imposed in California and their Anglo-Saxon neighbors tried to run them off by telling them that it was illegal for Mexicans to hold a claim. Reportedly, the Murrieta brothers tried to ignore the threats as long as they could until they were finally forced off their claim. Angry and unable to find work, Joaquin turned to a life of crime, along with other disposed foreign miners, who began to prey upon those who had forced them from their claims.

Murrieta soon became one of the leaders of a band of ruffians called The Five Joaquins, who were said to have been responsible for cattle rustling, robberies, and murders that occurred in the gold rush area of the Sierra Nevadas between 1850 and 1863. Comprised of Joaquin Botellier, Joaquin Carrillo, Joaquin Ocomorenia, and Joaquin Valenzuela, and Murrieta’s right-hand man Manual Garcia, known as “Three-Fingered Jack,” the tales of their crime spree included stealing over 100 horses, making off with more than $100,000 in gold, and killing 19 men.

With posses trailing after them, the bandits were able to avoid the law for several years, killing three lawmen in the process. When travel through the goldfields was made nearly impossible by the Five Joaquins, a bounty was placed on Murrieta’s head for $5,000. Finally having had enough of the Five Joaquins as well as the rest of the lawlessness in California, Governor John Bigler created the “California Rangers” in May 1853. Lead by former Texas Ranger, Harry Love, their first assignment was to arrest the Five Joaquins.

Joaquin Murietta by Charles Christian Nahl

Joaquin Murietta by Charles Christian Nahl

On July 25, 1853, the rangers encountered a group of Mexican males near Panoche Pass in San Benito County. In the inevitable gunfight that ensued, two of the Mexicans were killed, one of whom was thought to have been Murrieta, and the other — his right-hand man, Manual Garcia.

As evidence of the outlaws’ deaths, they cut off Garcia’s hand and Murrieta’s head and preserved them in a jar of brandy. Seventeen people, including a priest, signed affidavits identifying the head as Murrieta’s and the Rangers involved received the $5,000 reward.

Murrieta’s grisly remains then began to travel throughout California, displayed in Stockton, San Francisco and the mining camps of Mariposa County, to curious spectators willing to pay $1.00 to see the “sight” of the dead bandit’s head.

But not long after he was killed, speculation began to arise that it had not been Murrieta who had been killed, especially when a young woman, who claimed to be his sister, viewed the head and said that it did not have a characteristic scar that her brother had. Others began to make reports that Marietta was seen in various places in California after his alleged death.

If his legend wasn’t enough during his short lifetime, it would soon grow larger when in 1854, the first “fictionalized” account of his life appeared in a San Francisco newspaper and a book by John Rollin Ridge. In The Life and Adventures of Joaquin Murrieta, Ridge portrayed Murrieta as a folk hero who had only turned to a life of crime after a mob of American miners had beaten him severely and left him for dead, hanged his brother, and raped and killed his wife. According to Ridge’s account, Joaquin was a dashing, romantic figure that, swearing to avenge the atrocities committed upon his family, committed his many crimes only in an effort to “right” the many injustices against the Mexicans.

Joaquin Murreita's Head Advertising, 1853

Joaquin Murieta’s Head Advertising, 1853

According to the tale, Murrieta fled from his claim only to set up a saloon in nearby Hangtown, where miners began to go missing. One by one, the dead bodies of the miners, all who were said to have been part of the killings at the Murrieta claim, turned up with their ears cut off.

After fourteen miners had been found dead or missing, a Hangtown settler identified Murrieta who fled once again. Before long, he had gathered up his outlaw gang and began to take out his vendetta against the white settlers through robbery and mayhem.  However, to his Mexican compatriots, he was generous and kind, giving much of his ill-gotten gains to the poor, who in turn helped to shelter him from the law.

There is no evidence that Ridge’s version of the tale is accurate; however, similar atrocities were committed on both Mexicans and Chinese who were living in California at the time.

Over the years, the telling of the tale continued to grow until the dead Mexican outlaw began to be called the Robin Hood of El Dorado and take on a symbolized resistance of the Mexicans to the Anglo-American domination of California. And all throughout Gold Country, tales were told of how the outlaw had stayed at this or that hotel, drank in various saloons, and those who claimed to have actually met or was robbed by the man.

As to what happened to Joaquin’s head, it was finally placed behind the bar of the Golden Nugget Saloon in San Francisco, until the building was destroyed by the 1906 earthquake.

The head itself would become yet a part of another legend – the ghost of Joaquin. Even today, the tales continue of Joaquin’s headless ghost riding through the old goldfields, crying like a banshee – “Give me back my head.”

 

© Kathy Weiser/Legends of America, updated February 2020.

Also See:

Hangtown or Bust

Outlaws Across America

Lawmen of the Old West

California – The Golden State

Outlaw & Scoundrels Photo Gallery

1 thought on “Joaquin Murrieta – Patriot or Desperado?”

  1. My name is don joaquin Murrieta I’m a direct descendent of Joaquin Murrieta orozco of the gold rush 1848 his reaction 1850 to 1853 thier has been many things written about Joaquin thru out the years alot of inaccurate stuff alot of writers filling in blanks from thier perspectives they say his name is Joaquin Carrillo Murrieta .not true rather his step brother his true name is above mentioned .he’s from Sonora trinchras (San Rafaelaltar alomito) he’s not blond with blue eyes rather black hair black eyes . He’s not from chili he’s from Mexico this enternate has has recorded misleading information to many people blurt out wat they’ve herd in volume to a point it is now become a falts fact from who his parents r to his true identity joaquins strong tactile defense was to create confusion to evade detection or to safe gard his identity our family has clearified these specifics regarding his true name parents and so further his true focus after evening the score there was no normalcy of life for him after that so he sole purpose from that point was to gather capital gain troops and weapons to take back California for his people he felt was taken this is in no way shape or form a justification wat he did was his reaction to wat he endured from the anglo miners at that time and if u look at the picture correctly he haven’t done to anyone that they had done to him prior he did wat he did in response to wat was done to him plain n simple but they labeled him a bandit I feel that no ne shouldn’t dish out wat that can’t handle if returned but back to the point thier r many stories im sure use read or heard and this one coming from a descend probably no different but do know Joaquin Murrieta orozco wa a real person with a family to provide n protect n he will be wat u determine based on ur perception is is who n wat ur mind holds him to . Also the iconic pic supposedly him turns out to be frank Marshall not happy about heat fraudulent move but its clearified n yesterday’s news tgank for ur time

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *