In December 1896, two men cased a bank in Blackwell, Oklahoma, when law enforcement grew suspicious and tracked them down. On December 4, 1896, a heavily armed posse of six men surrounded a shack near Bert Benjamin’s ranch outside of Blackwell. Intending to capture a gang of bank robbers, Deputy Sheriff Alfred Lund called to the men inside the cabin: “Throw up your hands!” Instead, the outlaws inside answered with a burst of gunfire. At once, three posse men turned and ran. However, Lund and two other men stayed and returned fire at the desperados. When the dust settled, the posse had killed one of the robbers and wounded another.

Lund initially thought he had “bagged” a much-wanted outlaw and ex-Doolin Gang member named “Dynamite” Dick Clifton, who was wanted for bank robbery and had a $3,500 reward on his head. Instead, the dead man inside the cabin, who was missing a finger, just like Clifton, was a petty thief named Buck McGregg, aka Dick Ainsley. The second wounded outlaw, Ben Cravens, was a rustler and murderer. The posse took him into custody, but he later escaped.

 

©Kathy Alexander/Legends of America, updated October 2026.