A posse was immediately dispatched. Anticipating this, the two bandits buried the heavy strongbox in order to put some distance between themselves and their pursuers. However, the posse soon caught up with the pair and when a gunfight ensued, Macallum’s partner was shot and killed in the melee. Macallum was arrested, convicted, and sent the Yuma Territorial Prison. Though questioned at length, the desperado refused to reveal the location of the buried loot.

However, while Macallum was serving his sentence he became very ill and upon his death bed, relayed the story to another inmate. When the prisoner was released he wasted no time in following up with the lead and headed to Canyon Station.

At the time, a man named Andy Goodwill was living in the Canyon Station building. Having no objections to the former prisoner’s search of the buried gold, the man spent several days in and around the area, diligently searching for a marker that Macallum had described to him. But as hard as he looked he just couldn't find the marker. Perhaps this was because Mr. Goodwill had cultivated an orchard and a large garden on the premises. Finally, the discouraged man gave up his extensive search and left the area.

Several years later a woman by the name of Nelle Clack would tell a story of how she believed that the bandits had used a cave in Clacks Canyon to hide out. The cave, formed by two large boulders, would have been an ideal hiding place to observe the movements going on at Canyon Station. It was there, that Nelle had found personal belongings left by someone who had obviously lived in the cave for a period of time.

Today, all that is left of Canyon Station is a few crumbling foundations at the end of a weed-chocked road. The loot from the stagecoach robbery was never recovered.

Kathy Weiser/Legends of America, © January, 2005

Return to Arizona Treasures